Interesting post by Fr. Anthony Chadwick

I haven’t had time to read it in great depth, but it has some interesting portions for sure.

But this is kind of strange:

Deborah’s transition, in solidarity with most of the community in which she worshipped, involved a rupture between her “false” Catholicism and her “true” Catholicism. She and they will have to live with that break in their spiritual experience. It is not for me to judge them or any of the other Anglicans who followed the Anglicanorum coetibus trajectory. However, many of us reject this “break” as harmful and unnecessary. Deborah has suffered, as she told me and expressed publicly on her blog. It was necessary for her, but it is not a convincing argument for the ACC to embark on a path in which it has never shown the slightest interest.

No, I would not say I experienced a rupture, but a development of doctrine. I would say I experienced a continuity into a deeper Catholicism, one that includes communion with the Bishop of Rome and bishops in communion with him as a key part.

But I do not see my previous view of myself as “Catholic” as false, just not complete, or not-fully-consistent with the Catholic Church’s definition.  As a Continuing Anglican I certainly had many elements of the Catholic faith that sadly I find missing among many contemporary cradle Catholics in the west.  But having a Catholic faith without belonging to the  Catholic Church no longer seemed to me an option.

That does not mean I look with scorn on my Continuing Anglican past, nor on my Baptist past.  I learned a lot and am grateful for all the teaching and  nourishment I received.

After all, it is what has led me to this point and for that I’m thankful.

And by the way, commentators—stop bashing each other and practice civility here or I’ll not publish your comments.

Fr. Anthony seems to default to a binary/black vs. white/ either/or thinking at times.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Interesting post by Fr. Anthony Chadwick

  1. Pingback: Interesting post by Fr. Anthony Chadwick | Catholic Canada

  2. Richard Grand says:

    You say you had a past as a “continuing Anglican”. Continuing from what in terms of your faith journey. You had never been an Anglican to continue from. It’s like someone saying they had joined a Roman Catholic Latin Mass community because they wanted to “continue” this tradition, but had never previously been a Roman Catholic.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s